This is not a list of ‘the best fics I have ever read’. Or even ‘my all time favourite fics’ (though a bunch of them also would qualify as same). This is more a listing of ‘those fics/series that have absolutely stuck with me, and I find myself going back and rereading them’.
In no specific order (vaguely organised by when I fell in love with them, perhaps?):
After the End, by Arabella and Zsenya. (Harry Potter)
Yes yes, the grandmother BNF fic of the Ron/Hermione fandom. It’s a post-Year 7 fic written pre-OotP. It’s good. It was interestingly speculative. Reading it gives you a solid insight into some of the tropes and speculations of the Three Year Summer from the OBHWF side of the fandom. But honestly? The reason it’s on this list is for Chapters 27 and 27 & 3/4. Two of the best chapters of Quidditch that have ever been written, in my opinion, and “Harry Potter is happy.” is guaranteed to make me cry every time I read the line.
Some days I need to be reminded what good journalism is, and why I love Harry and all the Weasleys. 27 and 27 & 3/4 remind me of that.
Okay yes, and the line ‘Neville turned left’ still makes me sob like a baby. But that’s a bit harder to reread.
Bagenders, by Lady Alyssa and Random Dent. (Lord of the Rings)
This one is only accessible by the wayback machine these days, I believe.
Lord of the Rings fanfic! Is it in character? Not really. Is it a Modern!AU, something I generally hate? Yup. Is it still hilarious and do I still quote bits of this series? Hell yes.
The Fellowship all living in a three bedroom semi together, immortal, and getting on each other’s nerves.
I’m here for ‘All Hail Delia’ and the Christmas stories and mince pie freezer tetris and ‘Vadko’ and the weird knitting circle of old ladies obsessed with Master and Commander.
Lust over Pendle and sequels, by AJ Hall. (Harry Potter)
I couldn’t do this list without an AJ Hall story, and Lust over Pendle narrowly edges out the Sherlock contenders in the ‘I will spend a rainy weekend rereading these’ stakes.
Yup, it’s that fic that everyone introduces to you as “the Harry Potter mystery series set in a tiny Wiltshire village called Malfoy Intrinsica …yes it is that Draco/Neville fic, why are you running away? I promise it works!” I should hate it, given my dislike of Draco Malfoy and the strand of Weasley-bashing that runs through it, but honestly it rises above those automatic nopes for me.
Draco Malfoy in this fic isn’t actually canon Malfoy, but he’s not completely LeatherPants!Draco either (though he has many of the snark tendencies of same). Draco has the problem that a lot of British aristocrats have: his family estate is extensive, cash-poor and in desperate need of structural repairs. Neville has a problem: his extended family remain deeply useless, underestimate his abilities constantly, and several are deeply disapproving of his relationship with Draco (on the ‘he’s a guy’, ‘he’s a MALFOY’ and ‘wasn’t he working for You Know Who?!?’ axes in about equal proportions). Together with Hermione, they hatch a plot to solve the first problem, only to be caught by the fall out from the second problem. Dissipation and Despair introduces the Rev. Peter Blakeney, as what is the genre of cosy British mysteries without the local helpful vicar? (I love him).
Intensely British, always heavily researched and set in their landscape, and just plain satisfyingly GOOD. If you like Dorothy L. Sayers, or you like the writing of people who like Dorothy L. Sayers you will probably enjoy this.
Graduate Vulcan for Fun and Profit, by lazulisong. (Star Trek XI)
You can try and tell me that this isn’t actually canonical, and I will ignore you.
Jim Kirk was the youngest crew member of the USS Kelvin, and every other person who survived the voyage likes to remind him of that fact. And keep an eye on their adopted nephew. This causes Jim some issues, as he would rather not have 300 terrifying Starfleet aunties and uncles poking their noses into his business. He’s especially not thrilled when, due to signing up late to Starfleet because of Pike, he finds himself stuck in Vulcan 101, as all other language options are full. Unfortunately for Jim, the professor teaching the class happens to be one of those interfering Starfleet uncles…
All the Bridge crew are here. It’s delightful, it’s heart-wrenching, it’s highly quotable, and best of all, it’s Tarsus fic.
The Sith Who Brought Life Day, by ophelia_interrupted. (Star Wars: OT)
This is an annual Christmas reread for me.
A couple of random Imperial officers make a bet that leads to one of them frantically researching to figure out the biggest mystery in the Galactic Empire: who was the pilot who blew up the Death Star? That officer then has to go and tell Darth Vader the results of his research.
The outsider point of view of the story is what makes it so good to go back to, time after time, because the audience knows what’s coming and the POV character does not. It’s the ultimate squirmy ‘I know something you don’t and it’s killing me to keep the secret’ story, with a killer last line.
Incident Report, by K’Sal. (Star Trek: TOS)
Kirk and Spock have to write incident reports about a conflict that has occurred aboard the Enterprise while they are hosting negotiations for two hostile species they have encountered. Both of them are leaving a lot of details out of those incident reports, which is gradually revealed through the fic.
Purely on my list as it’s my absolute favourite all time ‘no really, K/S are secretly Vulcan married. Except they’re also concealing it from EACH OTHER’ story. Those doofuses.
Petyaverse, by Lanna Michaels (Vorkosigan)
You want me to choose between my children? Then it’s definitely the Petyaverse, above and beyond any other Vorkosigan fic. If I had to pin down one particular fic, it’s probably either Asylum, which is the start of the Escobar AU split (it’s the ‘I doubt the existence of the Emperor’s honour’ conversation that does it), or A Child’s Winterfair On Barrayar, though be fair the former works well enough on its own as long as you understand the concept who Petya is, whereas most of the joy of the latter comes from knowing Petya’s deeply, deeply broken perspective on the universe and seeing it in a 6 year old.
Piotr Pierre Vorkosigan is the big brother Miles deserved.
Epic, sprawling, full of internal AUs and an ever-expanding timeline, Lanna will stab you through your heart with a knife when you least expect it. I’m still waiting for the fic where Petya actually goes through with his constant threat of marrying the nearest respectable High Vor woman to obtain a Proper Heir and then angsting for approximately 80k over the fact that he gave his wife permission to ‘seek affections elsewhere’ so it’s not cheating, but he’s still too noble to do so himself. (Whichever AU it is where Petya marries Alys because Padma asked him to – I think it might be Escobar? – DOES NOT COUNT due to it sidestepping the majority of Petya’s angst).
The Stone Gryphon, by rthstewart (Chronicles of Narnia)
A Narnia series set in England during World War 2, looking at the impact on the Pevensie siblings being adults in children’s bodies, featuring a lot of Digory Kirke and Polly Plummer and adding Eustace and Jill once their Narnia adventures occur? Yes please.
Peter is sent to Oxford over the summer to study with Professor Kirke in anticipation of his upcoming university entrance, where he meets colleagues and friends of Digory’s who are palaeontologist archaeologists. Susan goes to Washington DC with their parents and ends up involved in the SOE spy ring operating over there. Edmund and Lucy have been dispatched to the Scrubbs for The Dawn Treader to occur. While there, Edmund encounters the American neighbours of the Scrubbs who include a Colonel who works at Bletchley Park and his family, while Lucy’s sense of political activism is awoken by news articles regarding the German concentration camps and the aiding and abetting of Polly.
And then it gets even better (Chapters 13 and 14 of Apostolic Way are also on my Christmas reread list).
Meticulously researched (read the recommended books; it’s worth it, trust me), it’s a joy and I really wish rthstewart was able to get to more of Lucy’s story, as she is my absolute favourite, but what we do get is So Damn Good.
The extended universe version of this is Everyone Lives, Nobody Dies, and features some delightful stories set well past the 1950s where all the characters get to grow up and get married and have families. My favourite story, if you twisted my arm, is probably Pigeon 40TW194 Reporting For Duty, because it's such a sweet look at the Pevensies in 2012. (My next favourite bits are 'any scenes at Lucy's school' and 'the time that Asim met Lucy').
Well Met at Mechanicsburg, by Persephone Kore and khilari. (Girl Genius)
Yes I am a living stereotype.
Do you like Girl Genius? Have you ever felt the desperate desire to knock all the characters’ heads together and get them to communicate? Then congratulations! This is the ‘Barry Actually Talks To Klaus After Rescuing Agatha’ fic. Everything gets immeasurably better. The OT3 have simultaneous breakthroughs as kids. Somehow everyone survives.
‘The Characters Actually Communicate’ is a deep well of fic in Girl Genius fandom, given the amount of the plot that hinges on pretty much everyone being too stubborn to tell another character what is going on, and assuming the worst of everyone’s motives. This is a classic of the genre and one of the best.
Pyeongchang and Prejudice, by AMarguerite. (Jane Austen)
Again, this is another story that I should hate, but god does it work. It’s a modern AU of Pride and Prejudice, including a handful of other favourite Austen characters, set in a Yuri on Ice!!! fusion with Figure Skating RPF. (Generally, you will not get me through the door on Austen modern AUs, fusion fics, or most RPF. A combination of all three? Argh)
Five times World Champion and Two Times Olympic Gold Medallist Fitzwilliam Darcy of Canada has recently retired at the age of 27 to coach rising star Charles Bingley in Men’s Singles. Jamie and Elizabeth Bennet are currently one of the US premier ice dancing couples, but placed disappointingly in the Sochi Olympics after Jamie had a panic attack and are only just getting back on track with their eyes on Pyeongchang.
At the 2016/17 Grand Prix Final banquet, Darcy comments to Bingley that the Bennet siblings are tolerably proficient, but will never get anywhere without better coaching and are lifelong bronze medallists. Lizzy overhears…
It’s Pride and Prejudice, you know how this story goes.
Featuring several tango-offs with Virtue-Moir, cameos by various Austen characters and international figure skaters, and a lot of YOI-based insights into the characterisation of the main characters, it’s funny and rereadable and manages to sneak the Stammi Vicino pair skate in as part of the last scene at the Pyeongchang Olympic exhibition.
Unless you already have a copy, you unfortunately can’t read this one, as the author has taken it down to shop it around as an actual novel (one of the perennial issues in Austen fandom). I’ll be fascinated to see the novel version and I’ll buy it, but I suspect a good chunk of the RPF references will disappear in the editing. There are a LOT of serial numbers to file.
If you want a AMarguerite P&P fic you can actually read, go for An Ever-Fixed Mark, a soulmark P&P fic, which is also wildly good. There are three separate endings to the fic: Lizzy ending up with Darcy, Colonel Fitzwilliam and the Duke of Wellington respectively, and if I had to choose one, I’d plump for the Colonel Fitzwilliam ending as the best one, though all three have their charms.